General legal information, not legal advice about your case. Laws change; check the statutes linked below or talk with an Illinois lawyer about your situation.
Whether you get a rental car after a crash depends mostly on whose insurance is paying. Illinois treats a claim against the other driver’s insurer differently from a claim under your own policy, and a court case has its own rule for “loss of use.”
Claim against the at-fault driver’s insurer
An Illinois Department of Insurance regulation covers rentals on property damage liability claims. Under 50 Ill. Adm. Code 919.80(d)(2), “in automobile property damage liability claims in which liability is reasonably clear, the company shall pay for the reasonable and necessary costs, in direct proportion to the extent of its liability, incurred in the rental of another automobile provided that the loss of use claim is submitted and substantiated.”
Three conditions sit in that sentence:
- Liability must be reasonably clear. Until it is, this rule does not require the payment.
- Payment is proportional. If the insurer’s driver was only partly at fault, the insurer pays that share of the rental. See comparative negligence for how fault is split.
- The loss of use claim must be submitted and substantiated. The rule does not list specific documents.
The Department’s third-party claim page explains how long and what kind of car: “The most the company must reimburse you for is the period of time it would normally take to repair your vehicle, or until they make you a settlement offer for your vehicle’s damage.” The regulation “does not specify the type of rental vehicle,” and “if your damaged vehicle is a specialty vehicle, the company does not have to pay for a rental of the same type.”
Some insurers pay a set amount per day instead of the actual bill. The same rule says that where the company “pays a flat rental amount per day, week or month, it must disclose to the claimant where the claimant can obtain a vehicle for the amount of its payment.”
Claim under your own policy
A rental under your own policy depends on the coverage you bought. On its first-party claim page, the Department answers “Can I Rent a Car?” this way: “It depends. If your vehicle is stolen, most insurance policies will reimburse you for the cost of a rental vehicle starting 48 hours after the theft, as long as you report the theft to the police and your insurance company. Check your policy for the dollar limits. For non-theft claims, most auto policies don’t provide for a rental vehicle, unless you bought additional rental car coverage for more premium.”
The Department also notes that even when another driver caused the damage, you may file with your own company if you have the appropriate coverages.
Loss of use if the case goes to court
If the claim is not settled and you sue the at-fault driver, the Illinois Pattern Jury Instructions, Civil include a separate item for loss of use. IPI 30.16 lets a jury award “the reasonable rental value of similar property for the time reasonably required for the [repair] [replacement] of the property damaged.” The comment adds: “It is not necessary that similar property be actually rented during the period of time reasonably required for repair,” but “proof as to the value of the loss of use must be present, such as the cost of renting a replacement vehicle.”
A lawsuit to recover damages for injury to property must be filed within 5 years after the cause of action accrued (735 ILCS 5/13-205). See Illinois car accident deadlines.
A dealer loaner while your car is in the shop
A new car dealer that lends you a free substitute vehicle while yours is being repaired or serviced does not have to follow the general rental rules in 625 ILCS 5/6-305(h), as long as you are told “orally or in writing” that the loaner “will be covered by his or her insurance policy.” In that case the statute says the customer “shall only be liable to the extent of any amount deductible from such insurance coverage in accordance with the terms of the policy.”
If the insurer delays or denies the rental
If the at-fault driver’s insurer will not pay, the Department lists your options as a claim under your own policy if you have the coverage, a small claims suit against the at-fault driver if the amount is within the county’s limit, or other legal counsel. Complaints can also be filed with the Illinois Department of Insurance. Our guide to a denied car insurance claim covers the written-explanation deadlines.
Frequently asked questions
Does the at-fault driver’s insurance have to pay for my rental car in Illinois?
Under 50 Ill. Adm. Code 919.80(d)(2), when liability is reasonably clear the insurer must pay the reasonable and necessary rental costs in direct proportion to the extent of its liability, as long as you submit and substantiate the loss of use claim.
How long will the other driver’s insurer pay for a rental?
The Illinois Department of Insurance says the most the company must reimburse is the period it would normally take to repair your vehicle, or until it makes you a settlement offer for your vehicle’s damage.
Does my own car insurance pay for a rental after an accident?
According to the Illinois Department of Insurance, most auto policies do not provide a rental for non-theft claims unless you bought additional rental car coverage. For theft, most policies reimburse a rental starting 48 hours after the theft if you report it to the police and your insurer.
Can I recover loss of use if I did not rent a car?
In a lawsuit, the comment to Illinois Pattern Jury Instruction Civil 30.16 says it is not necessary that similar property actually be rented, but there must be proof of the value of the loss of use, such as the cost of renting a replacement vehicle.
Related guides
- Car insurance claim denied in Illinois
- What to do after a car accident in Illinois
- Comparative negligence in Illinois car accidents
- Illinois car accident deadlines
Sources: 50 Ill. Adm. Code Part 919 (919.80(d)(2)); Illinois Pattern Jury Instructions, Civil (index); IPI Civil Chapter 30, Damage Instructions (PDF; IPI 30.16); 625 ILCS 5/6-305; 735 ILCS 5/13-205; IDOI: Filing a Claim with Another Driver’s Insurance Company; IDOI: Filing a Claim with Your Own Insurance Company; IDOI: File a Complaint. Last reviewed October 2026 by the Trafficstop.com editorial team.
Trafficstop.com is not a law firm and this page is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.
