Insurance Fraud in Illinois: What Counts and the Penalties

General legal information, not legal advice about your case. Laws change; check the statutes linked below or talk with an Illinois lawyer about your situation.

For drivers, insurance fraud in Illinois usually means a claim built on a lie: a staged crash, a car reported stolen that wasn’t, damage or injuries inflated after a real collision, or a false story about who was driving. Illinois treats it as a crime under 720 ILCS 5/17-10.5, and the same conduct can also cost the person who did it in civil court and with their own insurer. This page explains what the law covers, the penalties, and how suspected fraud is reported.

What the law treats as insurance fraud

Under 17-10.5(a)(1), a person commits insurance fraud when they knowingly obtain, try to obtain, or cause someone else to obtain, by deception, control over an insurance company’s or self-insured entity’s property by making a false claim. A few points follow from that wording:

  • An attempt counts. The claim doesn’t have to be paid. Trying to collect on a false claim is enough.
  • Helping counts. “Causing to be obtained” reaches people who set up or assist with a false claim, not only the person whose name is on it.
  • It has to be knowing. An honest mistake about the date, the damage or what happened isn’t fraud. The statute targets deception.

Common driver examples include arranging a crash to collect, adding old damage to a new claim, claiming injuries that didn’t happen, reporting a car stolen to get rid of it, and changing the facts of a crash to fit coverage.

Criminal penalties by amount

17-10.5(d) grades the offense by the value of the property obtained or attempted:

Value or conductClass
$300 or lessClass A misdemeanor
More than $300, up to $10,000Class 3 felony
More than $10,000, up to $100,000Class 2 felony
More than $100,000Class 1 felony
Aggravated: 3 or more separate frauds within 18 monthsClass 1 felony
Organizing an aggravated insurance fraud schemeClass X felony

On conviction, the court also orders restitution to the insurer, including its court costs and attorney’s fees.

Civil liability on top of a criminal case

Under 17-10.5(e)(1), a person who commits insurance fraud is civilly liable to the insurer for the greater of 3 times the value obtained, or 2 times the value attempted if nothing was obtained, plus attorney’s fees and costs. The rule cuts both ways: under (e)(2), an insurer that loses a bad-faith suit it based on a fraud claim can owe the policyholder 2 times the value plus fees.

Illinois also has an Insurance Claims Fraud Prevention Act. 740 ILCS 92/5 makes it unlawful to knowingly pay anyone, in cash or in kind, to steer people into making insurance claims. A violation of the Act or of 17-10.5 carries a civil penalty of $5,000 to $10,000 for each fraudulent claim, plus up to 3 times the amount of each claim. If someone offers you money to see a particular provider or to bring in a claim after a crash, that is the conduct the Act targets.

Lies on an insurance application

Fraud doesn’t only happen at claim time. 215 ILCS 5/154 says a misstatement in buying a policy can void it only if the statement appears in the policy or the written application and was made with actual intent to deceive or materially affected the insurer’s decision or risk. For auto and other covered policies, a policy can’t be rescinded on that basis after it has been in effect for one year or one policy term, whichever is shorter.

Cancellation is a separate tool. After a policy has been in effect for 60 days, 215 ILCS 5/143.19 lets an insurer cancel only for listed reasons, which include a policy obtained through material misrepresentation, failing to disclose crashes and moving violations from the past 36 months when the application asked for them, and any insured making, or knowingly helping with, a false or fraudulent claim. Showing an officer an insurance card you know is false is a separate violation (see 625 ILCS 5/7-602). For how ordinary tickets affect a policy, see insurance after a ticket in Illinois.

How suspected fraud gets reported

215 ILCS 5/155.24 requires an insurer that reasonably believes a motor vehicle theft or claim fraud has happened to tell an “authorized governmental agency.” That is the agency that took the original report, or, if none did, the Attorney General or the county State’s Attorney. The list of authorized agencies also includes the Illinois State Police, local police and sheriffs, the Department of Insurance and the Secretary of State. Insurers must also release claim information to those agencies on written request. The information shared is privileged, and the statute gives those who share it as the law provides protection from civil liability.

A correction to a common assumption: Illinois doesn’t have a general state insurance fraud bureau. The Illinois Department of Insurance said in Company Bulletin 2025-06 that it hasn’t adopted rules under Section 155.23, that its only criminal investigation unit handles workers’ compensation fraud, and that consumers who were defrauded in an insurance transaction should use its complaint process. That process is on the Department of Insurance complaint page.

What to do if you suspect fraud, or are accused of it

  • If you think a crash was staged or the other driver’s story changed afterward, tell the police officer at the scene and your insurer, take photos, and get the report through how to get a crash report in Illinois.
  • If an agent or company misled you about a policy or kept your premium without coverage, file a complaint with the Department of Insurance.
  • If your claim is denied for suspected fraud, ask for the reason in writing and review your options on car insurance claim denied in Illinois. A denial isn’t a criminal charge, but answer questions accurately; correcting a mistake promptly is very different from standing by a false statement.
  • If you are contacted by police or charged, talk with a criminal defense attorney before giving a statement. The felony classes above carry serious consequences.

Frequently asked questions

Is insurance fraud a felony in Illinois?

It can be. Under 720 ILCS 5/17-10.5, fraud involving $300 or less is a Class A misdemeanor, but more than $300 up to $10,000 is a Class 3 felony, and higher amounts are Class 2 or Class 1 felonies. Three or more frauds within 18 months is aggravated insurance fraud, a Class 1 felony.

Is it fraud if the insurance company never paid the claim?

It can be. The Illinois statute covers knowingly trying to obtain an insurer’s property through a false claim, not only succeeding. If nothing was paid, civil liability is 2 times the value attempted, plus attorney’s fees.

Can my insurer cancel my policy for a false claim?

Yes. After a policy has been in effect for 60 days, 215 ILCS 5/143.19 allows cancellation only for listed reasons, and one of them is that any insured made a false or fraudulent claim or knowingly helped someone else present one.

Can a mistake on my application void my car insurance?

Only in limited cases. Under 215 ILCS 5/154, a misstatement must be in the written application or policy and must have been made with intent to deceive or have materially affected the insurer’s risk. For auto policies, rescission isn’t allowed after one year or one policy term, whichever is shorter.

Where do I report insurance fraud in Illinois?

Report a staged crash or false claim to the police and your insurer. Insurers must pass suspected motor vehicle fraud to the agency that took the report, or to the Attorney General or State’s Attorney. If you were defrauded in an insurance transaction, file a complaint with the Illinois Department of Insurance.

Related: What to do after a car accident in Illinois · Illinois insurance requirements and minimums · Driving without insurance in Illinois

Last reviewed October 2026.

Trafficstop.com is not a law firm and this page is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.