Damaged a Rental Car in Illinois? What You Can Be Charged

General legal information, not legal advice about your case. Laws change; check the statutes linked below or talk with an Illinois lawyer about your situation.

If a rental car is damaged or stolen while you have it, Illinois law lets the rental company hold you responsible, but 625 ILCS 5/6-305.2 puts limits on what it can collect and how. This guide covers those limits and how your own insurance fits in.

You can be held liable for damage during the rental

Section 6-305.2(a) says a person who rents out a vehicle “may hold the renter liable for physical or mechanical damage to the rented motor vehicle that occurs during the time the motor vehicle is under the rental agreement.” The rest of the section limits how that claim is calculated and collected.

Limits on what the company can collect

  • Actual repair cost only. A claim “must be reasonably and rationally related to the actual loss incurred.” The company “shall mitigate damages where possible” and may not collect a physical damage claim that “exceeds the actual costs of the repair, including all discounts or price reductions” (6-305.2(e)).
  • No double recovery. The company may not hold you liable “for any amounts that the rental company recovers from any other party,” such as another driver’s insurer (6-305.2(c)).
  • No up-front damage charge. A rental company may not require “a deposit or an advance charge against the credit card of a renter, in any form, for damages to a vehicle” in your possession. When you return the car damaged, it may not require any payment for the damage “until after the cost of the damage to the vehicle and liability therefor is agreed to between the rental company and renter or is determined pursuant to law” (6-305.2(f)).

Theft of the rental car

If the rental car is stolen, subsections (b) and (b-5) cap your liability at the actual and reasonable costs of the loss up to a dollar limit that depends on whether the vehicle’s MSRP is above or below $50,000. The statute raises those limits every year by a set formula and does not state the current figure. The caps do not apply if it is established that the renter or authorized driver failed to exercise ordinary care, or committed or helped commit the theft; then damages can run up to the vehicle’s fair market value.

Before collecting the amounts in subsections (b) or (b-5), the company must get an estimate “from a repair company or an appraiser,” make a copy available on request to the renter or the renter’s insurer, and submit a copy with its claim (6-305.2(d)). For a vehicle with an MSRP over $50,000, it must also give your personal insurance company reasonable notice and a chance to inspect, and in a theft, reasonable notice of the theft (6-305.2(d) and (d-5)).

Sending the claim to your own insurer

Under 6-305.2(g), “if insurance coverage exists under the renter’s personal insurance policy and the coverage is confirmed during regular business hours, the renter may require that the rental company must submit any claims to the renter’s personal insurance carrier as the renter’s agent.” The company may not say, in writing or out loud, that it will not present claims to or negotiate with your insurer. After coverage is confirmed, “the amount of claim shall be resolved between the insurance carrier and the rental company.”

Whether your personal policy covers a rental car, and for how much, depends on the policy. Under 625 ILCS 5/6-305(f), a rental company may charge separately for optional items, including optional insurance, where “the renter can avoid incurring the charge” by choosing not to obtain or use them.

Loaner cars from a dealer

If a new car dealer lends you a free substitute vehicle while your own car is being repaired or serviced, 6-305(h) applies instead: the dealer is outside the section’s rental rules as long as the customer is made aware “orally or in writing” that the loaner will be covered by the customer’s insurance policy, and the customer is liable only “to the extent of any amount deductible” under that coverage.

Damage to other people

Damage you cause to other people or their property in a rental car is a separate question from damage to the rental itself. Under 625 ILCS 5/9-101, an owner who rents vehicles for hire must have proof of financial responsibility on file with the Secretary of State, and the usual crash duties still apply. See what to do after a car accident in Illinois and Illinois crash report requirements.

If you dispute the bill

The statute gives you a right to the repair estimate and keeps the company from demanding payment for damage on return until the amount and liability are agreed or decided by law. If the amount is still disputed, it can be decided in court.

Frequently asked questions

Can an Illinois rental car company charge my credit card for damage when I return the car?

No, not until the amount is settled. Under 625 ILCS 5/6-305.2(f), a rental company may not require a deposit or advance charge against your credit card for damage, and may not require payment for damage on return until the cost and liability are agreed to or determined pursuant to law.

Can the rental company charge more than the repair cost?

No. Section 6-305.2(e) says the company must mitigate damages where possible and may not collect a physical damage claim that exceeds the actual costs of the repair, including all discounts or price reductions.

Can I make the rental company deal with my own insurance company?

Yes, if coverage exists under your personal policy and is confirmed during regular business hours. Section 6-305.2(g) lets you require the rental company to submit claims to your insurer as your agent, and the amount is then resolved between the insurer and the rental company.

What if the rental car is stolen while I have it?

Sections 6-305.2(b) and (b-5) cap your liability for theft at actual and reasonable costs up to a statutory limit that rises each year, unless you failed to exercise ordinary care or were involved in the theft, in which case damages can reach the vehicle’s fair market value.

Related guides

Sources: 625 ILCS 5/6-305.2; 625 ILCS 5/6-305; 625 ILCS 5/9-101. Last reviewed October 2026 by the Trafficstop.com editorial team.

Trafficstop.com is not a law firm and this page is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.