Borrowed Car Accident in Illinois: Whose Insurance Pays?

General legal information, not legal advice about your case. Laws change; check the statutes linked below or talk with an Illinois lawyer about your situation.

Borrowing a friend’s or relative’s car is common, and so is the question that follows a crash: whose insurance pays? In Illinois the answer usually starts with the car owner’s policy, but it depends on what that policy says about other drivers, whether you had permission, and whether you have a policy of your own. This page walks through the statutes that set the floor and the steps to take after a crash in a car you don’t own.

The car has to be insured, and the owner can’t lend it otherwise

625 ILCS 5/7-601(a) does two things. It bars anyone from driving a vehicle on Illinois roads without liability coverage meeting the minimums in Section 7-203, and it bars an owner from permitting someone else to drive a vehicle that isn’t covered. So when a car is lent without insurance, both the person who lends it and the person who drives it can be in violation.

The owner also has a licensing duty. Under Section 6-304, no one may knowingly allow a person to drive their vehicle if that person isn’t authorized to drive under the Code, for example because they have no valid license.

Whose insurance responds first

Insurance generally follows the car first and the driver second, but the details come from the policies themselves. Three statutory points help:

  • Certified owner’s policies cover permitted drivers. Under Section 7-317(b)(2), an owner’s policy certified as proof of financial responsibility (such as one filed with an SR-22) must insure the named insured and anyone using the vehicle with the named insured’s express or implied permission, at least at the 7-317(b)(3) limits of $25,000/$50,000 for injury and $20,000 for property damage. Many ordinary policies use similar permissive-user wording, but that is a matter of the contract, so read the policy.
  • Your own policy may add coverage. An operator’s policy under 7-317(c) covers the named person while driving vehicles they don’t own, and 7-317(g) and (i) allow coverage above the minimum and proration with other valid insurance. That is how a driver’s own policy can sit on top of, or share with, the owner’s policy. If you don’t own a car but borrow one often, see non-owner SR-22 insurance in Illinois.
  • The insurance card carries a warning if permitted drivers aren’t covered. Section 7-602 requires the card in the car to warn when the policy doesn’t cover a driver using the vehicle with the owner’s permission. Before you borrow a car, it is worth looking at the card for that warning.

Whether a claim lands first on the owner’s policy, the driver’s policy, or both is decided by each policy’s “other insurance” terms, not by a single statute. Report the crash to the owner’s insurer and to your own, and let them sort out priority.

Why permission matters

The permissive-user rule turns on whether the owner said yes, or whether permission can fairly be implied, for instance from a pattern of lending the car. A driver who took the car without permission generally can’t rely on the owner’s coverage, and the owner may then be treated very differently under the Safety Responsibility Law (see car accident without insurance in Illinois for how that law treats vehicles used without the owner’s permission). If permission is disputed, write down what was said and when as soon as you can.

If the borrowed car turns out to be uninsured

A driver can be ticketed under Section 3-707 for operating an uninsured vehicle even if it isn’t theirs. The fine is more than $500 and up to $1,000, and the Secretary of State suspends driving privileges for 3 months on a conviction. Failing to display proof when asked is treated as having no insurance, but no conviction can rest on that alone if the driver later shows the court that coverage was in effect at the time. More detail is on driving without insurance in Illinois.

A crash in an uninsured car can also trigger a security deposit and possible license suspension under the Safety Responsibility Law, unless the driver has their own policy covering non-owned vehicles. If someone else was hurt and neither policy applies, their own uninsured motorist coverage may come into play; see uninsured motorist accidents in Illinois.

Damage to the borrowed car itself

Liability coverage pays for harm to other people and their property. Damage to the borrowed car is usually a question for the owner’s collision coverage, if the owner has it, along with any deductible. Owners and borrowers often settle this between themselves, but if it becomes a dispute, a lawsuit for damage to property generally has to be filed within 5 years under 735 ILCS 5/13-205. Injury claims have a shorter, 2-year limit under Section 13-202; see the Illinois car accident statute of limitations.

Steps after a crash in a car you don’t own

  1. Stop, check for injuries and call for help if needed. The general duties after a crash don’t change because the car is borrowed; see what to do after a car accident in Illinois.
  2. Show the owner’s insurance card. Section 7-602 requires the driver to carry evidence of insurance and show it to an officer on request. Paper or a phone image both count.
  3. Exchange information and note the owner’s name, the vehicle details and the policy number on the card.
  4. Tell the owner right away, and notify the owner’s insurer and your own. Most policies require prompt notice and cooperation.
  5. Handle crash reporting. Check whether a written report is required in your situation on Illinois crash report requirements, and get a copy of the police report later through how to get a crash report in Illinois.
  6. Keep records of photos, repair estimates, medical visits and anything said about permission.

Frequently asked questions

Does insurance follow the car or the driver in Illinois?

Usually the owner’s policy on the car responds first, and the driver’s own policy may add coverage. For an owner’s policy certified as proof of financial responsibility, 625 ILCS 5/7-317(b)(2) requires coverage for anyone driving with the owner’s express or implied permission. For other policies, the policy wording controls.

Can I get a ticket for driving someone else’s uninsured car?

Yes. 625 ILCS 5/7-601(a) bars anyone from operating an uninsured vehicle, and the driver can be charged under 3-707 even if they don’t own the car. A conviction carries a fine of more than $500 up to $1,000 and a 3-month suspension.

Is the owner responsible if they lend their car to someone?

The owner must keep the car insured and can’t let anyone drive it uninsured (7-601) or knowingly let an unlicensed or unauthorized driver use it (6-304). How the owner’s policy covers the crash depends on its terms and on whether the driver had permission.

How can I tell if the owner’s policy covers me before I borrow the car?

Look at the insurance card in the car. Under 625 ILCS 5/7-602, if the policy doesn’t cover a driver using the vehicle with the owner’s permission, the card must carry a warning about that limit. The owner can also check the policy itself.

Who pays for damage to the car I borrowed?

Liability coverage pays for other people’s losses, not the borrowed car. Damage to the borrowed car usually falls to the owner’s collision coverage, if any. If the owner and driver disagree, a property damage claim generally must be filed within 5 years under 735 ILCS 5/13-205.

Related: Illinois insurance requirements and minimums · Passenger injury claims in Illinois · Comparative negligence in Illinois

Last reviewed October 2026.

Trafficstop.com is not a law firm and this page is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.