General legal information, not legal advice about your case. Laws change; check the statutes linked below or talk with an Illinois lawyer about your situation.
Most animal collisions in Illinois involve deer, but cattle, horses and dogs cause crashes too. Who pays depends mainly on what kind of animal it was. A wild deer has no owner to claim against, so the question is your own coverage. A cow or a dog usually has an owner, and Illinois statutes say when that owner is responsible.
Hitting a deer or other wild animal
With a wild animal there’s normally no one else to file against, so the claim goes to your own policy. Which coverage applies isn’t uniform. The Illinois Department of Insurance’s Teen Drivers guide defines collision coverage as paying for damage to your car in a collision regardless of fault, and comprehensive coverage as paying for non-collision losses such as fire, theft and hail. It then notes that if your car hits an animal, some insurers treat it as a collision claim and others as a comprehensive claim. Read your policy, or ask your agent, which one yours uses. The difference can change the deductible and whether the claim is covered at all if you carry only one of the two.
Liability-only policies pay for damage you cause to others, not damage to your own car. If you swerved and hit another vehicle, though, that other driver’s losses can become a liability claim.
Keeping a road-killed deer
Illinois lets residents keep a deer killed by a vehicle, under rules in 17 Ill. Adm. Code Part 750:
- The driver involved in the collision has first claim to the deer. If the driver doesn’t take it, another Illinois citizen may.
- Only Illinois citizens who are not delinquent in child support may possess it. The IDNR road-kill page adds that non-residents may not claim one.
- Possession must be reported to the Department of Natural Resources within 24 hours, and the claimant keeps the Report ID until the deer is used up.
- No salvage tag is needed, but parts of a vehicle-killed deer may not be bartered or sold (750.30).
Apart from law enforcement and certain authorized officials, it’s illegal to kill a deer crippled by a vehicle collision (750.30(c)). Call police instead.
Hitting livestock on the road
Illinois law bars owners from letting livestock run at large. Under the Domestic Animals Running at Large Act, owners must provide the restraints needed to keep livestock in and are liable in a civil action for all damages caused by animals running at large (510 ILCS 55/1).
The same section gives owners a defense. An owner or keeper isn’t liable for injury caused by an animal that got loose without their knowledge if they can show they used reasonable care to restrain it. In practice, the questions are about fences, gates and prior escapes, so evidence matters early:
- Photograph the animal, any brand or ear tag, the fence line and any open gate or gap.
- Note where the animal came from and whether neighbors have seen it loose before.
- Ask the responding officer to record the owner’s name if it’s identified at the scene.
Dogs and other owned animals
The Animal Control Act makes an owner liable for the full amount of an injury proximately caused when a dog or other animal, without provocation, attacks, tries to attack or injures a person who is peaceably conducting themselves where they’re lawfully allowed to be (510 ILCS 5/16). That language plainly fits a bite. Whether it reaches a dog that runs into the road and causes a car or bicycle crash depends on the facts and on court decisions this page doesn’t cover. Owner negligence claims may also be possible. This is a good point to get a lawyer’s view, especially when the crash caused injuries. Cyclists should also read bicycle accidents in Illinois.
Swerving and fault
Swerving to miss an animal can turn a minor hit into a rollover or a crash with another car. If another driver is hurt, fault is weighed on the facts: speed, visibility, distance and whether the move was reasonable. Under 735 ILCS 5/2-1116, a person more than 50% at fault recovers nothing, and anyone at 50% or less has damages reduced by their share. See comparative negligence in Illinois.
What to do after hitting an animal
- Pull over where it’s safe, turn on hazard lights and check for injuries. Don’t approach an injured large animal.
- Call police, especially if the animal is in the roadway, someone is hurt, or another vehicle is involved. IDNR reminds motorists to report deer crashes when reporting is required; see Illinois crash report requirements.
- Photograph the vehicle, the animal and the scene, including fences or gates for livestock.
- Report the claim to your insurer and ask whether it will be handled under collision or comprehensive.
- If the animal had an owner, gather their name and contact information and keep the crash report. See how to get a crash report and the filing deadlines.
Frequently asked questions
Does insurance cover hitting a deer in Illinois?
Usually only if you carry physical damage coverage on your own car. The Illinois Department of Insurance notes that some insurers handle an animal strike as a collision claim and others as a comprehensive claim, so check which coverage your policy uses. Liability-only coverage doesn’t pay for your own car.
Can I keep a deer I hit in Illinois?
Yes, if you’re an Illinois citizen not delinquent in child support. The driver has first claim. You must report possession to IDNR within 24 hours and keep the Report ID, under 17 Ill. Adm. Code 750.10. No part of the deer may be bartered or sold.
Who pays if I hit a cow or horse on an Illinois road?
The owner may. Under 510 ILCS 55/1, livestock owners must restrain their animals and are liable for damages caused by livestock running at large. An owner isn’t liable if the animal got out without their knowledge and they show they used reasonable care to restrain it.
Is a dog owner liable if their dog causes a car accident?
Possibly. Under 510 ILCS 5/16, an owner is liable when a dog, without provocation, attacks, tries to attack or injures a person who is lawfully where they are. Whether that covers a dog that runs into traffic depends on the facts and court decisions, and negligence claims may also apply.
Am I at fault if I swerve to avoid an animal and hit another car?
It depends on the facts, such as speed, visibility and whether swerving was reasonable. Under 735 ILCS 5/2-1116, a person more than 50% at fault recovers nothing, and someone 50% or less at fault has damages reduced by their share.
Related: What to do after a car accident · Road debris accidents · If your car is a total loss
Sources: 510 ILCS 55/1; 510 ILCS 5/16; 735 ILCS 5/2-1116; 17 Ill. Adm. Code Part 750; IDNR, Claim a Road Kill; Illinois Department of Insurance, Teen Drivers.
Last reviewed October 2026.
Trafficstop.com is not a law firm and this page is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.
