Car Totaled in Illinois: Total Loss Claim Rules

General legal information, not legal advice about your case. Laws change; check the statutes linked below or talk with an Illinois lawyer about your situation.

When your own insurance company decides your vehicle is a total loss, an Illinois Department of Insurance regulation sets the ground rules for the settlement. 50 Ill. Adm. Code 919.80(c) applies when the policy settles first-party vehicle claims “on the basis of actual cash value or replacement.” Within 7 days after the total-loss determination, the company must give you at least the information listed in Exhibit A of the rule, and it must then settle by one of the methods below.

Replacement or cash: the two settlement methods

Replacement. If the company chooses to replace your vehicle, the replacement must be by the same manufacturer, same year, similar body style, and similar options and price range, “in as good or better overall condition,” and available for inspection at a licensed dealer within a reasonable distance of your home (919.80(c)(1)(A)). Replacements of the current model plus the 3 previous model years must be bought through licensed dealers unless you waive that in writing. The company must tell you where the vehicle is and its replacement value, including taxes, license and transfer fees.

If you would rather have cash, the company “need pay only the amount it would have otherwise paid on the replacement vehicle,” but only after it has first offered you the replacement and you have rejected the offer (919.80(c)(1)(C)). The company also may not require you to locate a replacement or travel unreasonably to inspect one (919.80(d)(1)).

Cash settlement. If the company pays cash, it must base the market value on one of the methods listed in 919.80(c)(2):

  • a published guide updated at least once every 2 months;
  • a computerized valuation source using data from the area around where your vehicle was principally garaged;
  • a computerized service that includes at least 2 vehicles currently available from, or recently sold by, licensed Illinois dealers located within 50 miles of the general metropolitan area where the data is gathered; or
  • if your vehicle is not quoted in those sources, at least two written dealer quotations, with the dealers’ names and locations and a copy of the quotations given to you.

Whatever method it uses, the claim file must document how the market value was determined (919.80(c)(2)(E)). The Department’s total loss consumer page adds that “ordinarily, however, advertisements are not acceptable sources of market value.”

Deductions the company can and cannot take

According to the Department, the company may deduct for old, unrepaired collision damage with no dollar limit, and may also deduct for wear and tear, missing parts and rust, “but the maximum deduction may not exceed $500.00.” All deductions must be itemized and specified as to dollar amount. Under the rule itself, 919.80(d)(4), deductions must be measurable, itemized, specified as to dollar amount and documented in the claim file. Deductions commonly called “get ready to go” or “dealer prep” charges are prohibited (919.80(c)(3)(B)).

Sales tax, title and transfer fees

With a replacement vehicle, the company pays the applicable sales tax and transfer and title fees. With a cash settlement, the rule works like this (919.80(c)(3)(A)):

  • If you buy or lease a vehicle within 30 days after you receive the settlement, the company must reimburse the sales tax and transfer and title fees you paid, up to the amount payable on the value of the totaled vehicle.
  • If the vehicle you buy is worth less than the settlement, the company reimburses only the tax and fees you actually incurred.
  • If the purchase and the payment of the taxes and fees are not documented to the company within 33 days after receipt of the settlement, the company does not have to reimburse them.
  • Instead of reimbursing later, the company may pay the taxes and fees to you at the time of settlement.

The 30-day right of recourse

If, within 30 days after you receive the claim draft, you cannot buy a comparable vehicle for the market value the company set, the company “will reopen its claim file” (919.80(c)(2)(F)). It then has these options:

  • locate a comparable vehicle for you at its market value, available through licensed dealers;
  • pay the difference between its market value (before deductions) and the cost of the comparable vehicle you found, or negotiate and buy that vehicle for you;
  • offer a replacement vehicle under the replacement rules; or
  • conclude the settlement under the appraisal section of your policy, which “shall be considered as binding against both parties.”

The company does not have to take these steps if its documentation at the time of settlement gave you written notice of a specific comparable vehicle, identified by VIN, that could have been bought for its market value before deductions (919.80(c)(2)(F)(v)).

Can you keep the totaled car?

Usually not. Under 625 ILCS 5/3-117.1(b)(1), once an insurance company pays a total loss claim it “shall be deemed to be the owner of such vehicle,” and the vehicle is treated as salvage. Only two kinds of vehicles may be kept by agreement between you and the insurer: a vehicle with only hail damage that does not affect its operational safety, or a vehicle 9 model years of age or older. The Department’s claim page notes the company “may, but is not required to let you keep your vehicle.”

Otherwise the title goes to the insurance company, and the statute has the insurer mail or deliver it to the Secretary of State within 20 days so a salvage certificate can be issued in the insurer’s name. Under 3-117.1(e), a salvage vehicle may not be driven on Illinois roads, a Class A misdemeanor, except in narrow cases such as a trip to or from the required inspection with special plates or under a short-term permit.

If you owe more than the car is worth

Asked whether the insurer will pay off a car loan, the Department answers: “No. Most insurance policies require your company to pay your vehicle’s actual cash value. If your vehicle’s value is less than your car loan, you must pay the difference.” The same page describes asking the lender about substitution of collateral.

Your own duties on the claim

The Department’s total loss page lists duties found in most policies: report the loss immediately, report suspected theft or vandalism to the police, protect the vehicle from further damage, cooperate with the company, and, under most policies, submit a sworn proof of loss within 91 days after the loss. Failing to do these things can lead to a denied claim. The Conditions section of your policy may add others.

When another driver caused the crash

The Department explains that you may file with your own company if you have the right coverage (a “first-party” claim) or with the other driver’s company (a “third-party” claim). The rules above are written for first-party claims. On a third-party claim, the Department notes there is no appraisal requirement, and a property damage claim must be settled or filed in court within 5 years (735 ILCS 5/13-205).

Complaints about how a company handles a claim can be filed with the Illinois Department of Insurance.

Frequently asked questions

Does my insurance company have to pay sales tax on a totaled car in Illinois?

Yes, under 50 Ill. Adm. Code 919.80(c)(3). With a replacement vehicle the company pays the sales tax and transfer and title fees. With a cash settlement, it reimburses the tax and fees if you buy or lease a vehicle within 30 days and send proof within 33 days, or it may pay them at settlement.

What if I cannot find a similar car for the settlement amount?

If within 30 days after receiving the claim draft you cannot buy a comparable vehicle for the company’s market value, 919.80(c)(2)(F) requires the company to reopen the claim. It may find you a comparable vehicle, pay the price difference, offer a replacement, or use the policy’s appraisal process.

Can I keep my car after the insurance company totals it?

Only if the car is 9 model years of age or older, or has only hail damage that does not affect its safety, and the insurer agrees. Otherwise 625 ILCS 5/3-117.1 makes the insurer the owner once it pays the total loss claim.

Will insurance pay off my car loan if my car is totaled?

Not necessarily. The Illinois Department of Insurance says most policies pay the vehicle’s actual cash value, and if that value is less than the loan, you must pay the difference.

Can the insurer deduct for rust or wear and tear?

Yes, but the Illinois Department of Insurance says deductions for wear and tear, missing parts and rust may not exceed $500.00, and all deductions must be itemized. Old unrepaired collision damage can be deducted without that limit.

Related guides

Sources: 50 Ill. Adm. Code Part 919 (919.80, Exhibit A); 625 ILCS 5/3-117.1; 735 ILCS 5/13-205; IDOI: Total Loss Auto Claims; IDOI: Filing a Claim with Your Own Insurance Company; IDOI: Filing a Claim with Another Driver’s Insurance Company; IDOI: File a Complaint. Last reviewed October 2026 by the Trafficstop.com editorial team.

Trafficstop.com is not a law firm and this page is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.